Market Report for Rentals in Bay Harbor Islands

Closed Sales as of 05-22-2025

$3,200
Median Closing Price

$3
Price Per Square Foot

95
Properties Sold In Last 180 Days

Recent Sales

Address	Closed Price	Listing Price	Living ft²	Cost per ft²	Bd / Ba	Closing Date	DOM
1080 94th St #412 Bay Harbor Islands, FL	$3,200	$3,500	1,330	$2	2 / 2	2025-05-16	141 Days
1075 93rd St #203 Bay Harbor Islands, FL	$2,300	$2,500	860	$3	2 / 1	2025-05-07	150 Days
1133 102nd St #601 Bay Harbor Islands, FL	$5,000	$5,200	1,368	$4	2 / 2	2025-05-06	105 Days
10190 E Bay Harbor Dr #9F Bay Harbor Islands, FL	$1,650	$1,750	800	$2	1 / 1	2025-05-01	30 Days
1135 92nd St #102 Bay Harbor Islands, FL	$2,750	$2,750	918	$3	2 / 2	2025-05-01	38 Days
9800 W Bay Harbor Dr #403 Bay Harbor Islands, FL	$3,350	$3,500	1,050	$3	2 / 2	2025-05-01	86 Days
10350 W Bay Harbor Dr #7D Bay Harbor Islands, FL	$3,850	$4,100	1,330	$3	2 / 2	2025-05-01	64 Days
10350 W Bay Harbor Dr #5J Bay Harbor Islands, FL	$2,700	$2,700	950	$3	1 / 1	2025-04-30	78 Days
9700 E Bay Harbor Dr #506 Bay Harbor Islands, FL	$2,200	$2,200	919	$2	1 / 1	2025-04-29	50 Days
1050 93rd St #2C Bay Harbor Islands, FL	$2,750	$2,700	1,095	$3	2 / 2	2025-04-29	128 Days
10000 W Bay Harbor Dr #503 Bay Harbor Islands, FL	$4,700	$4,800	1,484	$3	2 / 2	2025-04-28	85 Days
9500 W Bay Harbor Dr #2E Bay Harbor Islands, FL	$2,800	$2,800	961	$3	1 / 2	2025-04-21	90 Days
9261 E Bay Harbor Dr #804 Bay Harbor Islands, FL	$7,400	$7,400	1,958	$4	2 / 3	2025-04-21	133 Days
9940 W Bay Harbor Dr #6A-S Bay Harbor Islands, FL	$5,500	$5,750	1,239	$4	2 / 2	2025-04-18	57 Days
10076 E Bay Harbor Dr #76A Bay Harbor Islands, FL	$2,100	$2,100	520	$4	1 / 1	2025-04-08	58 Days
9270 E Bay Harbor Dr #7B Bay Harbor Islands, FL	$1,700	$1,750	500	$3	/ 1	2025-04-07	7 Days
1250 98th St Bay Harbor Islands, FL	$8,500	$8,500	2,495	$3	4 / 3	2025-04-07	48 Days
10350 W Bay Harbor Dr #6R Bay Harbor Islands, FL	$4,000	$4,000	1,379	$3	2 / 2	2025-04-02	163 Days
9700 E Bay Harbor Dr #510 Bay Harbor Islands, FL	$2,000	$2,000	832	$2	1 / 1	2025-04-01	38 Days

Active Listings For Sale Overview

$3,925
Median Listing Price

$3
Price Per Square Foot

128
Active For Sale

Min: $1,300 Max: $24,500

View all Active Listings

Active For Sale

Address	Sale Price	Living ft²	Bd / Ba	DOM
1135 103rd St #403 Bay Harbor Islands, FL	$24,500	3,097	3 / 4	116 Days
1135 103 #505 Bay Harbor Islands, FL	$20,000	2,514	2 / 3	21 Days
1150 102nd St #706 Bay Harbor Islands, FL	$15,000	1,202	2 / 2	36 Days
1260 99th St Bay Harbor Islands, FL	$15,000	2,093	4 / 2	16 Days
1065 99th St Bay Harbor Islands, FL	$14,000	2,157	4 / 3	51 Days
9400 W Bay Harbor Dr #302 Bay Harbor Islands, FL	$13,500 +8% ($1,000)	2,547	3 / 3	67 Days
10281 W Bay Harbor Dr #301 Bay Harbor Islands, FL	$13,200	1,925	3 / 3	45 Days
10281 W Bay Harbor Dr #201 Bay Harbor Islands, FL	$13,000	1,925	3 / 3	45 Days
1135 103rd Street #203 Bay Harbor Islands, FL	$12,500	2,333	3 / 3	15 Days
1000 99th St #5 Bay Harbor Islands, FL	$11,000	2,507	3 / 4	44 Days
10281 W Bay Harbor Dr #501 Bay Harbor Islands, FL	$10,600		2 / 2	45 Days
9901 W Bay Harbor Dr #401 Bay Harbor Islands, FL	$9,999 -26% ($3,501)	1,670	3 / 3	92 Days
1000 99th St #11 Bay Harbor Islands, FL	$9,900 -1% ($50)	2,519	4 / 4	256 Days
9901 E Bay Harbor Dr #301-302 Bay Harbor Islands, FL	$9,500	2,312	3 / 3	20 Days
9350 Bay Harbor Ter #1100 Bay Harbor Islands, FL	$9,500 -5% ($500)	3,500	4 / 3	108 Days
9350 Bay Harbor Ter #9356 Bay Harbor Islands, FL	$9,250 -3% ($250)	3,500	4 / 3	212 Days
1000 99th St #9 Bay Harbor Islands, FL	$9,000	2,720	4 / 4	99 Days
9901 W BAY HARBOR DR #602 Bay Harbor Islands, FL	$9,000	1,236	2 / 2	16 Days
9881 E Bay Harbor Dr #205 Bay Harbor Islands, FL	$9,000 -20% ($2,250)	1,254	2 / 2	218 Days
9350 Bay Harbor Ter #9350 Bay Harbor Islands, FL	$8,990	3,500	4 / 3	28 Days
1000 99th St #3 Bay Harbor Islands, FL	$8,950	2,900	5 / 4	11 Days
1000 99th St #14 Bay Harbor Islands, FL	$8,600 -13% ($1,300)	2,519	4 / 4	318 Days
10065 Bay Harbor Ter Bay Harbor Islands, FL	$8,000 -5% ($400)	3,000	5 / 3	117 Days
9901 W Bay Harbor Dr #702 Bay Harbor Islands, FL	$7,500	1,236	2 / 2	50 Days
1150 102nd St #403 Bay Harbor Islands, FL	$7,500	1,986	3 / 3	51 Days
10201 E Bay Harbor Dr #602 Bay Harbor Islands, FL	$7,500 -6% ($500)	1,384	2 / 2	36 Days
9821 E Bay Harbor Dr #302 Bay Harbor Islands, FL	$6,900	1,222	2 / 2	11 Days
10271 E Bay Harbor Dr #4 Bay Harbor Islands, FL	$6,500 -46% ($5,500)	1,300	3 / 2	443 Days
9821 E Bay Harbor Dr #PH-905 Bay Harbor Islands, FL	$6,500 -13% ($1,000)	1,141	2 / 2	226 Days
9200 W Bay Harbor Dr #1A Bay Harbor Islands, FL	$6,500 -16% ($1,200)	2,200	3 / 2	100 Days
9821 E Bay Harbor Dr #402 Bay Harbor Islands, FL	$6,200	1,142	2 / 2	60 Days
9940 W Bay Harbor Dr #3A-N Bay Harbor Islands, FL	$6,000	1,239	2 / 2	13 Days
9821 E Bay Harbor Dr #501 Bay Harbor Islands, FL	$6,000 -8% ($500)	947	2 / 2	50 Days
9881 E Bay Harbor Dr #302 Bay Harbor Islands, FL	$6,000 +14% ($750)	860	1 / 1	218 Days
9821 E Bay Harbor Dr #805 Bay Harbor Islands, FL	$5,900	1,141	2 / 2	4 Days
9940 W Bay Harbor Dr #5A-N Bay Harbor Islands, FL	$5,900	1,239	2 / 2	2 Days
9881 E Bay Harbor Dr #301 Bay Harbor Islands, FL	$5,900 -21% ($1,600)	1,510	2 / 2	218 Days
10140 W Bay Harbor Dr #603C Bay Harbor Islands, FL	$5,800 -8% ($500)	1,840	3 / 2	34 Days
9102 W Bay Harbor Dr #5-D Bay Harbor Islands, FL	$5,800	1,820	2 / 2	23 Days
9821 E Bay Harbor Dr #503 Bay Harbor Islands, FL	$5,800 -6% ($400)	1,143	2 / 2	24 Days
1150 101st St #202 Bay Harbor Islands, FL	$5,750	946	2 / 3	126 Days
9261 E Bay Harbor Dr #404 Bay Harbor Islands, FL	$5,600 +19% ($900)	1,303	2 / 2	457 Days
9521 E Bay Harbor Dr #905 Bay Harbor Islands, FL	$5,500	1,019	1 / 2	64 Days
9901 E Bay Harbor Dr #703 Bay Harbor Islands, FL	$5,500	1,150	2 / 2	19 Days
1133 102nd St #301 Bay Harbor Islands, FL	$5,500 -5% ($300)	1,368	2 / 2	67 Days
1170 101st St #402 Bay Harbor Islands, FL	$5,375 -0% ($25)	1,434	2 / 2	21 Days
1101 101st St #8 Bay Harbor Islands, FL	$5,350	1,923	3 / 2	41 Days
9100 W Bay Harbor Dr #5A Bay Harbor Islands, FL	$5,300 -12% ($700)	1,770	2 / 2	64 Days
1150 102nd St #406 Bay Harbor Islands, FL	$5,200	1,211	2 / 2	53 Days
1133 102nd St #507 Bay Harbor Islands, FL	$5,200	1,503	3 / 3	39 Days

View All Active Listings : Rentals in Bay Harbor Islands

Request an in-depth Market Report

First Name

Last Name

Phone

Comments

Please check box to continue.

By clicking "Submit and Stay Updated" and providing lilliscoastalrealty.com (Lillis Coastal Realty) your contact information, you acknowledge and agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Service ... Read More

and consent to receiving marketing communications, including through automated calls, texts, and emails, some of which may use artificial or prerecorded voices. This consent isn't necessary for purchasing any products or services and you may opt out at any time. To opt out from texts, you can reply, 'stop' at any time. To opt out from emails, you can click on the unsubscribe link in the emails. Message and data rates may apply.

Real Estate Portfolio

Luxury & Waterfront Aventura Bal Harbour Bay Harbor Islands Brickell Coconut Grove Coral Gables Cutler Bay Doral Downtown Miami Edgewater Midtown Fisher Island Golden Beach Homestead Kendall Key Biscayne Miami Beach Miami Shores North Miami Beach Palmetto Bay Pinecrest South Beach South Miami Sunny Isles Beach Surfside Venetian Islands Upper East Side West Miami

Contact

Katie Lillis
Broker / Owner
(786) 269-5115
Katie@LillisCoastalRealty.com

Company

Lillis Coastal Realty
Miami Beach, FL

Explore

New & Pre-Construction
Luxury Homes
Luxury Condos
Advanced Search